So, (I realize starting with "So" already shows my conflict about this book) I'm listening to "The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet" by Becky Chambers. I'm on the last few laps (5 more chapters of 23.) An agent I was researching said it's one of their favorite books. And I read the blurb, and it sounded like my cuppa. So I got it. Has anyone read this book?
What I'm enjoying: Massive world building. Massive. Many (!) alien races all with their own unique stuff (physiology, history, customs, cultures, planets, methods of communication, etc) interesting tech, interesting history of what happened to humans, interesting state of the universe/politics, etc. I am also enjoying the core characters. It's a space romp, so the MC's are the crew of this spaceship. The 7 crew (one new member, so that EVERYTHING HAS TO BE EXPLAINED -- more of this later) are all very different, and incredibly well crafted. Even the AI one, and the unlikable one.
What I'm not enjoying: As hinted, EVERYTHING is explained, what you need, what you might need, what you don't need, what you will definitely never ever need... It feels like the author just wanted you to know all this cool shit she came up with, and whenever she felt like telling you. It's obvious that a LOT of work went into imagining it all, and gosh darn it, you're going to hear alllll about it! And that unfortunately, takes up all the air instead of plot. The plot is like a wafer-thin mint. There aren't holes, becasue there isn't enough of a plot to punch holes into. It's more a series of unconnected events, that are all character/tech/species related. If you just looked at plot, you could lift out most of the first 3/4's of the book, and not lose any of the core plot. That just pisses me off. Because I love plot.
HOWEVER... I am still listening. And I will finish it. Because I have grown to really like a few of the characters. And just now, in chapter 19, we have FINALLY reached the Small Angry Planet, and it looks like we might, I live in hope, get a plot.
/rant
UPDATE! I did finish the book, and the last act was great. The book is not strong on plot overall, but I did enjoy it in the end.
What I'm enjoying: Massive world building. Massive. Many (!) alien races all with their own unique stuff (physiology, history, customs, cultures, planets, methods of communication, etc) interesting tech, interesting history of what happened to humans, interesting state of the universe/politics, etc. I am also enjoying the core characters. It's a space romp, so the MC's are the crew of this spaceship. The 7 crew (one new member, so that EVERYTHING HAS TO BE EXPLAINED -- more of this later) are all very different, and incredibly well crafted. Even the AI one, and the unlikable one.
What I'm not enjoying: As hinted, EVERYTHING is explained, what you need, what you might need, what you don't need, what you will definitely never ever need... It feels like the author just wanted you to know all this cool shit she came up with, and whenever she felt like telling you. It's obvious that a LOT of work went into imagining it all, and gosh darn it, you're going to hear alllll about it! And that unfortunately, takes up all the air instead of plot. The plot is like a wafer-thin mint. There aren't holes, becasue there isn't enough of a plot to punch holes into. It's more a series of unconnected events, that are all character/tech/species related. If you just looked at plot, you could lift out most of the first 3/4's of the book, and not lose any of the core plot. That just pisses me off. Because I love plot.
HOWEVER... I am still listening. And I will finish it. Because I have grown to really like a few of the characters. And just now, in chapter 19, we have FINALLY reached the Small Angry Planet, and it looks like we might, I live in hope, get a plot.
/rant
UPDATE! I did finish the book, and the last act was great. The book is not strong on plot overall, but I did enjoy it in the end.
Last edited: