Read It Like You Stole It!

Daily Writing Tip Widget

J

Help! Manuscript request - still waiting!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Paul Whybrow

Full Member
Jun 20, 2015
Cornwall, UK
This report from the book section of the Guardian newspaper shows that we shouldn't worry too much about our work being pirated :

http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/jul/24/ebook-pirate-uk-statistics-2015

It's easy to worry about someone copying your plotline, or of having inadvertently borrowed key elements from a novel that you read ten years ago and had largely forgotten about. There's only so many stories under the sun, and it's reckoned that there are only seven (or five) basic plots, so there's bound to be some coincidences.

It's quite likely that someone has written a thriller that contains elements of my novel, which is about a war-hardened mercenary who's killing victims as part of some twisted role-play game. After all, there's been much reporting on how computer games induce violent acts in real life, and more people are aware of the ongoing trauma of PTSD for veteran soldiers. I was more concerned that another author would get their book published before mine, with the same title of The Perfect Murderer.

I like catchy titles, and though there's nothing crucial about my narrative that would prevent me changing the title, I'd still be a bit miffed that someone beat me to it. Mind you, I was a bit surprised that a famous crime novelist, H.R.F. Keating had written his first Indian detective story featuring Inspector Ghote with the title The Perfect Murder. I probably read it when I was in my twenties, forgetting the story but storing a form of the title in my memory banks.

Some theft does occur with books. It's impossible to take legal action against those who've stolen your entire story if it's in the Far East - unless you're a major corporation, and tough even then. A writer friend who published a series of romance novels as ebooks in the U.K. went to visit friends in India. They'd read her books, and tentatively showed her some pirated versions of them, which had been printed as paperbacks with the Western names changed to Indian, along with other cultural details referring to clothing, food and religion.

There was absolutely nothing that she could do about it, and the supposed author looked to be a made-up identity for an online search found nothing about them. My friend moved on through Asia, as part of her post-retirement backpacking adventure, ending up in China. She wasn't entirely surprised to find her romances were on sale in street markets, again altered to represent the country.

She hadn't used Digital Rights Management for her ebooks, not thinking that such foreign piracy would ever occur. DRM is easily removed anyway.

We might be more widely read than we know...
 
Did she introduce herself as the original writer to the street market people, I wonder? Or buy copies as she travelled.

I don't think that she did, for she's rather a shy person. It wouldn't have done any good anyway, for counterfeiting rules in some Asian countries, as well as Russia. A friend who worked as a nanny in Singapore and Moscow, used to buy bootleg versions of CDs and DVDs, as well as handbags and clothing, for a fraction of the price of the real thing.

Back in 2003, when I was still living in America, I put together a business plan to start a T-shirt printing venture. In the U.K. this sort of company has the worst record for failure within a year of starting up, but in Atlanta there was a lot of positive feedback and with the marketplace being so huge I thought that my idea stood a good chance. My T-shirts has a couple of unique selling points to their construction, and sported some pithy sayings from literature. On a surge of optimism, I mentioned my design ideas online - this was a big mistake. A couple of months later, a friend who travelled internationally as a software designer returned from Beijing. He handed me a wrapped present, with a wicked grin on his face, and I opened it to find one of my designs on a bright pink T-shirt. He knew about my plans, and saw the shirt in a neighbourhood gift store. They'd even copied the unique hidden pocket and personalised label features.

They were charging one fifth the price that I could expect to make, even by selling online. I accepted defeat.
 
The other day, I looked up a new short story by a friend of mine, JJ Toner, named Zugzwang. (Here, those who read/speak German will get the point...) Seemed like a really unique title to me at least, but when I did a title search, there were more than ten books of all kinds by that name. His short was fourth or so on the list. It was a very, very fitting title as it turned out, but name alone isn't enough for the search engines, I guess. My first novel, which was initially commented on here, was titled The Red Gate, but I can't seem to get away from The Secret of Red Gate Farm whenever I do a title search. I give up. "Unique" and "easy to remember" must be mutually exclusive. My current WIP is being titled River Traffic, but I doubt it's even going to show up on the first page of like titles. ;)
 
Wow, I just tried that with my Merlin and Ceridwen and it pops right up at the top, that's actually amazing. But with Ceridwen, that as a name is fairly rare so it helps ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Daily Writing Tip Widget

J

Help! Manuscript request - still waiting!

Back
Top